Advantages and Disadvantages of Testamentary Trusts

Testamentary trusts offer many benefits, particularly when it comes to asset protection. Their unique structure, which separates control and benefit, ensures that assets are safeguarded from legal actions and beneficiaries who may make poor financial decisions. By keeping the estate intact, testamentary trusts help protect your estate from potential bankruptcy and court orders. However, while the advantages are appealing, it’s important to weigh them against the potential disadvantages. Here’s a deeper look into the pros and cons of testamentary trusts.

Advantages of Testamentary Trusts

  1. Asset Protection
    One of the primary benefits of a testamentary trust is its ability to protect assets from legal action and from beneficiaries who may not handle financial matters wisely. Because the assets are held within the trust and not directly by the beneficiaries, they are less vulnerable to claims from creditors or legal disputes.
  2. Tax Advantages
    Testamentary trusts provide significant tax benefits, particularly in terms of income, capital gains, and franked dividends. Income distributed to beneficiaries from the trust is not taxed at the trust level but is taxed at the beneficiaries’ marginal tax rates. Trustees have the flexibility to distribute income in a way that minimizes tax liabilities. For example, they can distribute income to beneficiaries in a manner that leverages lower tax brackets. This means more of the estate’s wealth stays in the hands of your beneficiaries.

Additionally, tax concessions apply not only to assets at the time of death but also to assets the trust acquires using the funds from the original estate. This makes the trust more tax-efficient in the long run.

  1. Pension Benefits
    Testamentary trusts can also have advantages for beneficiaries who are eligible for pensions. Since the trust’s assets aren’t considered when determining pension eligibility, beneficiaries can still receive their full pension benefits while enjoying distributions from the trust.
  2. Capital Gains Tax
    When assets are transferred to the testamentary trust, there is typically no capital gains tax on the transfer itself, nor on proceeds from life insurance policies or superannuation death benefits. This ensures that the bulk of the estate value is preserved for the beneficiaries.

However, depending on the jurisdiction, capital gains tax may apply to assets acquired by the trustee after the death, so it’s important to consider this factor.

Disadvantages of Testamentary Trusts

  1. Taxes on the Family Home
    One potential drawback is that the family home, if held in the testamentary trust, may lose its capital gains tax exemption. The impact of this can vary depending on your financial situation and location, so it’s essential to seek advice from a financial adviser to understand how this might affect your estate.
  2. Cost of Administering the Trust
    Administering a testamentary trust comes with costs. If you appoint a professional trustee, you will incur fees. There are also ongoing costs for accounting services and tax preparation. These administrative fees can diminish the value of the estate, so it’s crucial to assess whether the benefits of the trust outweigh the costs.

For those uncertain about the benefits, a testamentary trust can be included as an option in the will, allowing the trustee to decide whether it is appropriate to implement.

When a Trust May Be Beneficial for Asset Protection

Testamentary trusts can be particularly valuable in specific situations:

  1. High-Risk Beneficiaries
    If any of your beneficiaries are in high-risk professions, such as law enforcement, military service, or owning a business exposed to negligence claims, a testamentary trust can shield their inheritance from potential liabilities.
  2. Creditor Protection
    Testamentary trusts can protect the inheritance from creditors, ensuring that beneficiaries’ debts do not diminish their share of the estate. It can also protect their inheritance from a spouse’s business liabilities or financial issues.
  3. Education Funding
    A testamentary trust can be an excellent tool for leaving money for a beneficiary’s education, including tuition and boarding school fees. The tax efficiency of the trust makes it a viable option for funding educational costs.
  4. Divorce Protection
    Assets in a testamentary trust are not considered personal property, which means they are not subject to division in the event of a beneficiary’s divorce. This ensures that your child’s inheritance remains protected.
  5. Protection Against Remarriage
    A testamentary trust can ensure that your surviving spouse doesn’t remarry and divert the estate to a new family, or squander it on unwise ventures. This type of trust gives you more control over how the estate is handled.
  6. Children with Issues
    If you have children with tendencies toward poor financial decisions, such as addiction or reckless spending, a testamentary trust can safeguard their inheritance and ensure it is used responsibly.
  7. Disabled Children
    For children with disabilities, a testamentary trust ensures that the inheritance is managed appropriately and used for their well-being. It can provide financial security without risking the loss of government assistance or benefits.

Conclusion

Testamentary trusts offer valuable asset protection and tax benefits, especially for those with complex family situations, high-risk beneficiaries, or specific estate planning goals. They provide control over how assets are distributed, offering peace of mind that your wishes will be respected, even in difficult circumstances like divorce, remarriage, or financial mismanagement by beneficiaries. However, it is important to consider the costs involved, the potential tax implications on the family home, and whether the benefits outweigh the administration fees. By carefully evaluating your personal situation and consulting with a financial adviser, you can determine whether a testamentary trust is the right tool to protect your estate and provide for your loved ones.

———————————————————————————————————————-

BOOK YOUR FREE 15 MINUTE CONSULTATION

We offer a 15-minute no obligation consultation to existing property investors, first home buyers and small business owners who are looking at property investments, business and asset protection.

Please complete the form and a member of our team will be in touch shortly- CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR FREE CONSULTATION

How can we help?

If you have any questions or would like further information or you are seeking property tax advice, please feel free to contact our office via email –info@investplusaccounting.com.au or phone 02 9299 7000 to either speak with someone or arrange a time for a meeting so we can discuss your requirements in more detail.

We have offices in Bankstown, Cronulla, Sydney CBD, Bowral, Liverpool, Adelaide, New Zealand and Dubai. You can arrange a free 15 minute no obligation chat to discuss your options. Please arrange an appointment with our office by clicking here

General Advice Warning

The material on this page and on this website has been prepared for general information purposes only and not as specific advice to any particular person. Any advice contained on this page and on this website is General Advice and does not take into account any person’s particular investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs.

Before making an investment decision based on this advice you should consider, with or without the assistance of a securities adviser, whether it is appropriate to your particular investment needs, objectives and financial circumstances. In addition, the examples provided on this page and on this website are for illustrative purposes only.

Although every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of the information contained on this page and on this website, Investment Plus Accounting Group, its officers, representatives, employees, and agents disclaim all liability [except for any liability which by law cannot be excluded), for any error, inaccuracy in, or omission from the information contained in this website or any loss or damage suffered by any person directly or indirectly through relying on this information.

Testamentary Trusts

Testamentary Trusts

Testamentary Trusts are discretionary trusts established in Wills, that allow the trustees of the trust to decide, from time to time, which of the nominated beneficiaries may receive the benefits of the distributions from the trust assets for any given period. 

 

Find out how we can help

Advantages of Testamentary Trusts

Control

A testamentary trust can be validly established for up to 80 years, and as such can benefit two or three generations, with the distribution of the trust’s income and assets being completely flexible. Testamentary trusts can be dissolved at any time as well as distributions made to the desired beneficiaries. These Trusts are designed to provide maximum flexibility as they allow for the tax effective distribution of capital and income from the assets and provide a greater degree of asset protection compared to assets held by beneficiaries in their personal capacity.

Asset Protection – Remarriage and de-facto relationships

If a Will is not correctly structured with the incorporation of testamentary trusts, and the deceased’s assets are distributed directly to their spouse, those assets may be at risk is a widowed spouse remarries or enters a de-facto relationship.

In a testamentary trust, if one spouse dies, and the other remarries, assets held in the trust can be protected for the benefit of the nominated beneficiaries – that is, the deceased own children and grandchildren.

Asset Protection – Solvency and third-party claims

Assets held by the trustee of a testamentary trust may be protected from potential third-party claims made against individual beneficiaries. If a beneficiary is experiencing solvency issues, it is possible that the inherited assets may be susceptible to claims made by creditors.

If the estate assets are distributed to and held by the trustee of a testamentary trust, those trust assets may be protected from a third-party’s claim against the individual beneficiary because the assets are held by the trustee for and on behalf of the beneficiaries, rather than the assets being held by the individual beneficiary and therefore being susceptible to third-party claims. The assets are not held by the beneficiary, but rather by the trustee for and on behalf of the beneficiary, with a discretion to distribute to any nominated beneficiary.

Asset Protection – Children and other beneficiaries

A testamentary trust is particularly beneficial for beneficiaries with intellectual disabilities, as well as beneficiaries will illnesses, addiction problems or other concerns which could result in the loss or dissipation of an inheritance.

If a child or other beneficiary is temporarily incapacitated, testamentary trusts will enable the assets to be managed by the family for the benefit of the beneficiary, rather than having a portion of the estate controlled by a government agency.

Under a Will, if a child or other beneficiary is experiencing solvency issues or is bankrupt at the time of the distribution, the beneficiaries may not receive the gift as creditors are able to claim it. Assets held in a testamentary trust are protected from a beneficiary’s creditors and claimants because the beneficiary has no actual entitlement to a distribution until the trustee determines it. This avoids the loss of an inheritance due to the bankruptcy or adverse financial circumstances of a beneficiary.

If a beneficiary is considered to be working within a high risk business or profession where negligence or other claims are a risk, a testamentary trust also protects the inheritance from these types of claims.

 

Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax

Under an ‘ordinary’ trust, if a beneficiary takes their inheritance in their personal name, they are required to pay tax on the income generated from the inheritance at the top marginal tax rate. This means if a child under the age of 18 receives over $1000, they must pay the associated tax at the top marginal rate. However, under a testamentary trust, children under 18 are taxed as ordinary taxpayers, starting at lower tax rates.

When compared to distributions made either directly, or under family law trusts, this results in considerable reductions in the total tax payable when distributions are made to children or grandchildren – until they reach the age of 18.

Capital gains realised on assets held by a testamentary trust can also be streamed to one or more beneficiaries in a tax effective way. Where one or more of the beneficiaries has a low income in the year of distribution, distribution to this beneficiary allows them to take better advantage of the 5-year averaging rate of capital gains tax losses.In turn, tax payable on capital gains realised assets can be considerably reduced.

Centrelink – Preservation of government benefits

Currently, Centrelink does not take into account the assets held by the trustee of a testamentary trust when calculating the pension eligibility of an individual beneficiary, although the income distributed by the testamentary trust is assessable under the Centrelink income test, as well as being taxable in the hands of the beneficiary.

Superannuation and Insurance payouts

Generally, superannuation proceeds fall outside the assets in a deceased estate and the distribution of the proceeds is determined by the rules of the fund. However, an individual (Will maker) may direct the trustee of the superannuation fund to pay the proceeds of the deceased’s superannuation or death benefits to the executor of the deceased’ estate.

In these circumstances the proceeds will be paid and distributed in accordance with the Will. If the Will includes a testamentary trust, then the proceeds may be directed by the executor to the trustee of a testamentary trust established in the Will, rather than being distributed directly to the nominated beneficiary (ies) and held in the beneficiaries’ personal capacity.

The proceeds will then be distributed to the executor of the deceased’s estate, who will have the discretion to distribute the proceeds and make use of the testamentary trusts established in the Will.

 

 

 

**Note

This article contains general advice only and does not take in account any person’s individual circumstances, needs or financial circumstances. This article is for general information only and must not be relied upon or as a substitute for legal or other specialised advice

 

Tell me how

Resources

How To Effectively
Protect Your Assets
Read the brochure

How to Set Up
A Family / Discretionary Trust

Read the brochure
20 Tax Tips
For Property Investors
Read the brochure

Book a no-obligation 15-minute consultation

We offer a 15 -minute no obligation consultation to existing property investors, first home buyers and small business owners who are looking at property investments, business and asset protection.

Please complete the form and a member of our team will be in touch shortly:

Contact Form

This form collects your information so that we can better serve you. We will never sell your information to any third party. View our Privacy Policy.